Sheath Underwear Reviews

I bought these as a gift for my brother, it was a bit hit or miss. He said the fit felt different from what he expected and took some time to get used to. The quality seems okay, but for the price, I really thought he’d like them more. They’re not bad, but I’d just warn people that they may not be for everyone, especially if you’re buying them as a gift.

My order ended up taking a lot longer than the estimate they showed at checkout, which was annoying. I emailed customer service and got a really basic response back, then basically had to wait around again before hearing anything useful. The product itself was fine once it finally arrived, but the whole shipping and support experience was just frustrating... not sure I’d be in a rush to order again.

I was shopping on my phone and it was just really easy, which is all I wanted. I found the sizes fast, the pages loaded quickly, and checkout didn’t make me jump through a bunch of annoying steps. Also no random popups blocking everything, thank goodness. So yeah, happy with the whole experience...

I’ve washed it loads of times now, and it’s still holding up fine. after so much washing I expected it to start looking worn out, but it still looks good and feels fine.

I wanted to like it, but when I saw it in person I was kind of like… hmm, this looks a little awkward. The style feels a bit dated to me, and it just wasn’t really my taste.

I’ve worn Sheath a handful of times now, i’m happy with them. The fabric feels soft without being flimsy, and after washing, it still doesn’t give off that cheap, worn-out vibe. Breathability has been solid too, I’m guessing from how they feel throughout the day that they’re made to avoid that sweaty, uncomfortable feeling some other pairs give me. The fit was mostly good, though they did feel a little snug at first. Overall, I like them a lot, I just wish the price was a bit easier to justify.

The brand seems solid. The site looks legit, the reviews are mostly good, and I’d feel comfortable ordering from them. Nice.

These are comfy enough, but I wish I’d gone up a size. The waist is tighter than I expected, so they’re not quite as relaxed as I was hoping...

The packaging was neat and looked good, maybe even a little nicer than I expected. Opening it felt good too, like they put some care into it.

Checkout was easy... I got through it without much trouble. The size options were clear, the cart made sense, and Apple Pay worked just fine for me.
The only thing was that the discount code box took me a minute to find on mobile. Not a huge deal, but... it could probably be a little more obvious...

I actually really like the underwear itself, but the color and pattern selection is where things get a bit underwhelming. The basics are fine and totally wearable, but I was hoping for more fun prints or a few different shades to choose from. So many of them look almost the same, like they all came from the same very cautious drawer. Not bad at all, just kind of a dramatic letdown if you’re looking for something with a little personality.

My first take was that these just aren’t worth it for me. They fit fine, so no big complaint there, but after a regular day the odor control had pretty much given up. I still felt sweaty and not exactly fresh. For the price, I expected them to perform a lot better.

I ordered a couple pairs from Sheath and the payment process was simple. The total on my card matched what I saw at checkout, shipping included, which is really all I want when buying online. No random add-ons or weird charges showed up later.
I’m giving 4 stars because the confirmation email took a bit longer than I expected, so I did wonder for a minute if the order went through. But in the end, the billing was correct, everything cleared normally, and that’s the main thing for me.

I liked their ethical claims, which is a nice change from the usual shopping experience of pretending not to think about where things come from. The fit was mostly good too, with only a couple small quirks, but overall I’m happy with it.

I checked out Sheath because they had a promo banner up and a discount code being advertised, so I figured I’d give it a shot. But when I got to checkout, the code either didn’t work properly or took off less than I thought it would, which was frustrating, honestly.

The underwear itself is fine, so I don’t really have a big issue there. I just wish the pricing and deals were clearer upfront instead of making customers mess around with coupons that don’t quite do what you expect

The checkout felt discreet and the package was plain enough that I didn’t feel awkward about it showing up. So in that sense, privacy was handled well. But at the same time, I ended up getting more follow-up emails than I really wanted after ordering, which made it feel a little less private than I expected. Not a huge deal, but also slightly annoying.

I really wanted to like them, but the styles felt limited. A lot of the pieces have the same basic look with just tiny changes, and I was hoping for more fun colors or different cuts. The quality seems fine, but I got bored browsing quickly. I also asked a couple of questions and kept getting inconsistent answers, which made the whole shopping experience more frustrating. Hopefully they add more options soon.

I really wanted to love these, but wow, they were not it for workouts. If I’m just hanging around the house, they’re fine, no big drama. But the second I took them to the gym, everything went off the rails. The pouch felt weird when I was running, the legs kept riding up during squats like they had a personal mission to annoy me, and after getting sweaty they felt heavy and uncomfortable. The waistband was okay, I guess, but for the price I expected way more. Maybe they’re decent for everyday wear, but for training? Hard pass from me.

I was glad they had my size in stock. That does not always happen. Ordering was quick. I did not have to wait around

I finally tried Sheath after getting fed up with regular boxer briefs sticking, bunching, and just being annoying all day. the only bad thing was my timing because I probably should’ve switched before a bunch of long work days where I was already uncomfortable. The pouch is definitely the main feature. It keeps everything separated without feeling strange or too tight. It took me about a day to get used to, but now regular underwear feels kind of irritating. The support is good for work, walking around, and staying comfortable through the day. They stay in place well too. They’re not exactly cheap, but for the comfort, I’d say they’re worth it.